The Sweetheart Deal

Image of The Sweetheart Deal
Release Date: 
May 19, 2015
Little, Brown & Company
Reviewed by: 

“a perfect summer read.”

The Sweetheart Deal is a solid first novel by Polly Dugan, which in spite of the sweetness of the title, never strays toward sappiness.

This story of loss and redemption opens in the husband’s point of view. Sadly, we never hear directly from Leo again. He dies in a freak skiing accident leaving his wife, Audrey, and her three young teen-aged boys seemingly alone.

The crux of the book is not about Leo’s death, however; it’s about a secret promise made by Leo’s best friend, Garrett—an accomplished and enthusiastic bachelor. Under drunken duress 12 years prior to Leo’s death, Garrett signs a slip of paper on which he promises to marry Audrey if she should ever become a widow.

Leo, a firefighter, lays it all out in the first couple sentences of the novel: “I know Garrett never thought I was serious when I told him, If I die, I need you to marry Audrey. Make my wife your bride—she’s meant to be a bride, not my widow.”

At the news of Leo’s death Garrett, who is in a tenure-track job at Boston College, drops everything in his life—including his current girlfriend—grabs the signed promise, and flies to Portland for the funeral. He plans for an extended stay in order to finish the addition to the house that Leo left behind.

The rest of the story follows its predictable path, but the writing is crisp and the characters are believable and likable making this a light, pleasant read. What also puts this novel a slight cut above its peers is the way author Dugan weaves together collective and individual grief by shifting points of view, adding depth and poignancy. Each chapter is from a different character’s viewpoint.

Soon after his father’s funeral the oldest of the boys, Christopher, takes a walk with one of his friends: “. . . we walked without talking until I started to cry, and without saying anything Joe put his hand on my shoulder and the weight of his hand helped me keep walking, and then I did both things. I kept walking and crying.”

While Garrett and Audrey are well developed, more time spent with the three boys—and even Leo—might have added the magic to make this novel truly masterful. The sudden shift to a more passive voice in the last few chapters is also disconcerting, causing a notable loss in momentum and leaving the ending a little flat.

Dugan is masterful in being true to Audrey and Garrett. She’s succeeded in crafting a heartening worthwhile journey into grief, redemption, and love. The Sweetheart Deal, filled with memorable engaging characters, is a perfect summer read.