Inspection: A Novel

Image of Inspection: A Novel
Release Date: 
March 19, 2019
Del Rey
Reviewed by: 

“Malerman’s world-building is rich, and Inspection’s quick chapters and brisk style make for a relentless, twisty read.”

Wild concept meets richly imagined narrative in Josh Malerman’s Inspection, a novel that contemplates a dark experiment aimed at improving intelligence by separating boys from girls.

If boys and girls can be reared without distractions, the theory goes, then each group will have more time to develop their genius.

Both groups must not encounter or interact with the other. In fact, each group must not learn of the other’s existence; never shall the twain meet!


Or it’s trouble. Serious trouble. The scientists mean business. Daily inspections—physical and verbal—are necessary to check that each group has remained unaware of the other.

Around this notion, Malerman (Bird Box, Unbury Carol) has built a detailed, fully realized world—turrets, Mister Tree, Alphabet Boys, Letter Girls, The Corner, The Parenthood, D.A.D., M.O.M., The Glasgow Tunnel, The Body Hall, Effigy Meets, an odd mind game called Boats, and more.

There is a Hogwartsian flavor as Malerman shows us around and explains how this closed-up world works. At the outset, the main point of view is one of the Alphabet Boys, J. But we are also given the dark-minded scientists and the writers who crank out books that reinforce the false narrative under which each camp is run. We are deep in the dark woods of northern Michigan, but the laboratory is disconnected from the outside world. This is all the Alphabet Boys and the Letter Girls know.

Malerman’s writing is matter-of-fact, non-showy. “Seated six at a table at four large round tops, most of the Alphabet Boys appeared charged by D.A.D.’s speech in the Body Hall. F, funny F, joked as freely as if the Parenthood had outlawed studying for the day. His large front teeth looked especially white in contrast to his black button-up shirt and the black blazer that hung over his seat back. J and D had long, privately, joked that F looked like a ‘living cartoon.’ They watched him talk, now, as they once smiled at drawings scribbled into the margins of their textbooks.”  

After a thorough introduction to the boys’ side of things, Malerman gives us the perspective of Letter Girl K. It’s hard to imagine a reader who wouldn’t surmise that J and K belong together and that the scientists’ brash experiment will soon collapse. Perhaps it all would have worked better if the boys were in Michigan, say, and the girls were in Mississippi. As Inspection begins, the children in both camps are in their “Delicate Years.” The implication is clear: puberty is nigh. Stuff happens. Curiosity, you know.

The scientists can’t control everything. In one case, it’s a rogue writer who publishes a bit of true news after years of conjuring elaborate fabrications. In another, it’s an overly inquisitive Letter Girl who has developed a keen eye and even sharper ability to sketch, a talent that comes in handy when she spots a few strange sights in a distant “Second Tower.”

There is one plot point that should make for an excellent Hunger Games-style action scene when the movie is made (and Inspection seems tailor-made for film).  It’s this: if K is standing in for all these bright girls and J is standing in for all these smart boys, it’s the female of the species who figures things out more quickly and works with a lot more tenacity to trigger the inevitable uprising. She’s a bright and special K.

“B looked to K, and in that moment both felt a seed rattle somewhere inside their bodies; perhaps this experience had the potential to grow into something bigger than either had planned on.

“K considered turning around. For the betterment of her sisters. Before she got them into something she hadn’t meant to at all.”

How the children were first rounded up requires a leap, and it’s a bit of a head-scratcher that a giant laboratory in the woods—several miles of forest separate the two camps—has somehow gone unnoticed for a dozen years or more. 

Minor leaps. Check your own talents for close inspection at the door and go for an entertaining ride. Malerman’s world-building is rich, and Inspection’s quick chapters and brisk style make for a relentless, twisty read.