Harmless Like You: A Novel
“Buchanan writes with a sharp and original artist’s eye of her own.”
Harmless Like You opens with a stunningly understated meeting in Berlin, as a narrator gives a small Japanese woman some legal papers to sign:
“‘Yukiko Oyama?’ I dropped my half-raised hand to my side. ‘You’re expecting me. I’ve come about your husband’s estate.’
“‘Come in,’ my mother said.”
In tracing the stories of Yukiko (or Yuki) and her son, Jay, this debut novel also explores deeper issues of identity. Author Rowan Hisayo Buchanan writes with beauty and sensitivity about what it means to be an artist, a parent, and an outsider in a foreign culture.
Unfortunately, that moment when Yuki and Jay finally reunite in Berlin, 33 years after she had abandoned him, falls flat—in part because nothing happens, and in part because by then, the reader just doesn’t like either one of them.
Growing up in New York City in the 1950s and 1960s as the daughter of an expatriate Japanese businessman, Yuki has never felt she belonged in any country. Her only friend is the dangerously charismatic Odile, who teaches Yuki to flirt with strange men in bars in order to rob them. So when her parents are recalled “home” to Japan in 1969, Yuki, then age 17, begs to stay behind and live with Odile and her mother, Lillian, a self-centered and vaguely New Age romance novelist.
Tentatively, Yuki dreams of a career as an artist—a career her parents would never accept.
Then Odile flies off to Italy for a whirlwind makeover as a top model. Now the only person who pays attention to Yuki is Lillian’s boyfriend, Lou, a sports writer with grand ambitions and disgusting eating habits who is more than twice Yuki’s age.
As Yuki discovers once she moves into his dirty apartment, Lou is also violent. He hits her when she reads his secret poetry, when the bed sheets are stained after she does the laundry, when they argue about the Vietnam War. And more.
By way of kiss-and-make-up, Lou says after one smackdown, “can you please, pretty please, just try not to piss me off, okay?”
Yet Yuki is so desperately insecure that she stays with Lou eight more years, until she finally turns to Edison Eaves, the nice young Canadian architect who has loved her all along. Like a Prince Charming, Edison whisks Yuki off to a house in the Connecticut suburbs with a yard swing and a bright room for her art studio.
But it obviously isn’t a fairy tale ending, because Yuki abandons Edison and their son when Jay is two years old.
By the time Jay finds her and the novel begins, Yuki is a little-known conceptual artist in Berlin, while Jay and his Chinese-American wife, Mimi, own a struggling art gallery in hipster Brooklyn.
(Yuki’s current show consists of photographs of white food on white plates —“cauliflower, rice, milk, rolls of cheese, crustless bread, skinless bananas, parsnips, sad strips of chicken breast”—during a month in which Yuki ate only white food, and entitled “Shit’s Still Brown.”)
Author Buchanan—who is of American, British, Chinese, and Japanese background—is best at describing the way an artist sees art and the world.
On Yuki’s first night in a new apartment, “She held the pencil perpendicular to the bed. The lines of perspective, each peeling tile, the battered plastic chair, the washstand’s belly . . . The grid pulled her on and on—into only white wall. When she was done, the room and the picture gave her twin stares.”
Indeed, Buchanan writes with a sharp and original artist’s eye of her own. When Mimi drinks too much, “she turned rosy as a twelve-year-old girl's bedroom.” Early in her relationship with Lou, “Yuki’s lungs tried to flap after him” as he walks past her desk.
The novel is also on target about the difficulty of living between cultures— especially for Yuki, as an Asian girl in the U.S. during the Vietnam War. When she meets American soldiers, she thinks: “Photographs of her aunts, grandmothers, great-aunts had stood on her parents’ offering table. Yuki saw their faces tearing, burning, and the light reflected in the eyes of those Camel-smoking, Coke-drinking, gum-chewing boys.”
The big problem is that the language is richer and deeper than the characters.
Certainly, the reader feels sympathy for Yuki and can even understand why she would stay with Lou. After a while, however—especially after she marries Edison—Yuki’s helplessness becomes annoying, and Edison’s saintly devotion is unbelievable.
Jay is even more self-pitying than his mother. Although he claims to love Mimi “so much it’s embarrassing,” he is grossed out by her pregnancy, miffed by her lack of interest in sex, and repelled by their newborn daughter, Eliot, whom he sees as “an inarticulate, pink flesh-sack.”
Of course it’s important to have complex, flawed characters with cringe-inducing traits; however, it’s also important to have characters the readers care about.
But Buchanan is still young. What she lacks is technical experience, not talent. Her descriptions of being an artist show that she truly is one.