Better Living Through Plastic Explosives
“. . . humorous and plot lines are deliciously original.”
A few years ago, Zsuzsi Gartner published All the Anxious the Girls, one of the most original, daring, and witty short story collections of this century. Now she returns with Better Living Through Plastic Explosives, a second collection of densely-written, intellectually-complex, and darkly humorous stories.
Set mostly in the affluent suburbs around Vancouver, Better Living Through Plastic Explosives takes a hard look at the people we’ve become. We are pretentious but lacking in education; we are politically correct but still small-minded. We whine about the demise of our environment while knowingly engaging in behaviors contributing to its degradation.
Ms. Gartner’s conclusions about us are pretty tough.
Though her conclusions about us may be grim, Ms. Gartner’s pen is humorous and plot lines are deliciously original. Favorite themes include manhood (or lack thereof), the misdirected sexuality of young women, and children rebelling against stifling upbringings. Faith, movies, art, terrorism, motivational speakers, and IKEA also get lined up for roasting.
Ms. Gartner’s writing is razor sharp. The following shows Ms. Gartner’s unique, cutting voice at its best: “Two teenage girls stop in front of Nina. It’s fall already, but they wear halter tops, nipples on high alert like shark fins patrolling the dangerous fabric, and too much kohl, making their porcine eyes look even smaller and meaner.”
There are at least 30 passages in Better Living Through Plastic Explosives that are this good.
At times, however, Ms. Gartner gets a little carried away with her gifts. The following story-within-a-sentence reveals Ms. Gartner’s occasional self-indulgence:
“Out on the balcony, while the photographer flips the steaks, their fat hissing against the fake briquettes like a clique of fashionable grade seven private-school girls, and tells her about watching a bridge blow up outside Sarajevo and how it was too close for comfort (emphasis his) and how a dog, a really ugly mutt, stood on one side of the nonexistent bridge whimpering and that all he wanted to do was take a picture of the dog, and not the bodies, and get out of there, Didi wonders whether it was unwise to have hinted so broadly last night to everyone up there on the roof that Annie Leibowitz might be at this other party tonight at the photographer’s place, which has turned out not be any kind of party at all.”
Though the line may be fuzzy, there still is a line between deploying a rapier-wit to make a point and sneering for the sake of sneering. More often than not, Ms. Gartner stays on the right side of this line. But this reviewer wishes Ms. Gartner, or her editor, showed a greater willingness to pare-back on these moments of excess. Just because an author is gifted enough to stuff four biting images into a single sentence, doesn’t mean she should. Even among the highly talented, restraint is a trait to be admired.
All the Anxious Girls launched Zsuzsi Gartner into the ranks of the most promising short story authors writing today. Better Living Through Plastic Explosives doubles down on Ms. Gartner’s strengths: biting social commentary, highbrow wit, and delicious plot lines. In the future, perhaps subtlety will also emerge among Ms. Gartner’s strengths.