I Is an Other: The Secret Life of Metaphor and How It Shapes the Way We See the World

Reviewed by: 

James Geary’s latest book on the nuances of the English language is called I Is an Other: The Secret Life of Metaphor and How It Shapes the Way We See the World. Its existence begs the question: Is there really enough to say about metaphors for a writer—even one as talented as Mr. Geary—to fill a 304-page book?

Yes—for the most part.

First, the metaphor. It is the act of giving one thing “a name that belongs to something else,” according to Aristotle. It is how we understand the world around us. Consider the following dialogue between a king and his philosopher subject in a story retold by the author:

[T]he King said to him: “If you have anything to say, I wish you would say it plainly and not resort to analogies.”

Hui Tze said, “Suppose there is a man here who does not know what a tan is, and you say to him ‘A tan is like a tan.’ Would he understand?”

“No,” the King said.

“Then were you to say to him ‘A tan is like a bow, but has a strip of bamboo in place of the string.’ Would he understand?”

“Yes, he would,” the King replied.

“A man who explains necessarily makes intelligible that which is not known by comparing it with what is known,” Hui Tze said.

I Is an Other opines that it is near impossible to write anything without the use of a metaphor. Consider this famous American sentence:

Four score and seven years ago, our fathers brought forth, upon this continent, a new nation, conceived in liberty, and dedicated to the proposition that “all men are created equal.”

Geary counts one metaphor for every fifteen words of Lincoln’s famous speech, which is even more surprising when he reminds us that the sum total of the Gettyburg’s Address is only 243 words.

The author further manages to weave together a fascinating amount of information on a seemingly mundane topic across chapters titled, among others: Metaphor and Money, Metaphor and the Mind, and Metaphor and Politics.

He seems to include everything on the subject, perhaps for the sake of completeness. This is not necessarily a good thing. Does a reader really need to know the neurological basis for particular conceptual metaphors? Arguably not, as it becomes less entertaining as it becomes more pedantic in the middle of the book.

Still, it’s a minor quibble. I Is an Other really shines when it focuses on the simple yet profound. “Juliet is the sun” is a sentence revisited by Geary throughout the book, and it’s an excellent choice: Is Juliet a ball of fiery gas? Or is she, to Romeo, the center of the universe and more?

Our ability to instantly understand what Shakespeare was really trying to say is a mark of both maturity and humanity, and Geary compellingly makes this point clear.

I Is an Other
feels like it could have been a superlative 250-page book instead of a very good 304-page book. Still, it has far more good points than bad points and you’ll never look at a metaphor the same way again—metaphorically speaking.

Long Description: 

James Geary’s latest book on the nuances of the English language is called I Is an Other: The Secret Life of Metaphor and How It Shapes the Way We See the World. Its existence begs the question: Is there really enough to say about metaphors for a writer—even one as talented as Mr. Geary—to fill a 304-page book?

Yes—for the most part.

First, the metaphor. It is the act of giving one thing “a name that belongs to something else,” according to Aristotle. It is how we understand the world around us. Consider the following dialogue between a king and his philosopher subject in a story retold by the author:

[T]he King said to him: “If you have anything to say, I wish you would say it plainly and not resort to analogies.”

Hui Tze said, “Suppose there is a man here who does not know what a tan is, and you say to him ‘A tan is like a tan.’ Would he understand?”

“No,” the King said.

“Then were you to say to him ‘A tan is like a bow, but has a strip of bamboo in place of the string.’ Would he understand?”

“Yes, he would,” the King replied.

“A man who explains necessarily makes intelligible that which is not known by comparing it with what is known,” Hui Tze said.

I Is an Other opines that it is near impossible to write anything without the use of a metaphor. Consider this famous American sentence:

Four score and seven years ago, our fathers brought forth, upon this continent, a new nation, conceived in liberty, and dedicated to the proposition that “all men are created equal.”

Geary counts one metaphor for every fifteen words of Lincoln’s famous speech, which is even more surprising when he reminds us that the sum total of the Gettyburg’s Address is only 243 words.

The author further manages to weave together a fascinating amount of information on a seemingly mundane topic across chapters titled, among others: Metaphor and Money, Metaphor and the Mind, and Metaphor and Politics.

He seems to include everything on the subject, perhaps for the sake of completeness. This is not necessarily a good thing. Does a reader really need to know the neurological basis for particular conceptual metaphors? Arguably not, as it becomes less entertaining as it becomes more pedantic in the middle of the book.

Still, it’s a minor quibble. I Is an Other really shines when it focuses on the simple yet profound. “Juliet is the sun” is a sentence revisited by Geary throughout the book, and it’s an excellent choice: Is Juliet a ball of fiery gas? Or is she, to Romeo, the center of the universe and more?

Our ability to instantly understand what Shakespeare was really trying to say is a mark of both maturity and humanity, and Geary compellingly makes this point clear.

I Is an Other
feels like it could have been a superlative 250-page book instead of a very good 304-page book. Still, it has far more good points than bad points and you’ll never look at a metaphor the same way again—metaphorically speaking.

Reviewed by: 

James Geary’s latest book on the nuances of the English language is called I Is an Other: The Secret Life of Metaphor and How It Shapes the Way We See the World. Its existence begs the question: Is there really enough to say about metaphors for a writer—even one as talented as Mr. Geary—to fill a 304-page book?

Yes—for the most part.

First, the metaphor. It is the act of giving one thing “a name that belongs to something else,” according to Aristotle. It is how we understand the world around us. Consider the following dialogue between a king and his philosopher subject in a story retold by the author:

[T]he King said to him: “If you have anything to say, I wish you would say it plainly and not resort to analogies.”

Hui Tze said, “Suppose there is a man here who does not know what a tan is, and you say to him ‘A tan is like a tan.’ Would he understand?”

“No,” the King said.

“Then were you to say to him ‘A tan is like a bow, but has a strip of bamboo in place of the string.’ Would he understand?”

“Yes, he would,” the King replied.

“A man who explains necessarily makes intelligible that which is not known by comparing it with what is known,” Hui Tze said.

I Is an Other opines that it is near impossible to write anything without the use of a metaphor. Consider this famous American sentence:

Four score and seven years ago, our fathers brought forth, upon this continent, a new nation, conceived in liberty, and dedicated to the proposition that “all men are created equal.”

Geary counts one metaphor for every fifteen words of Lincoln’s famous speech, which is even more surprising when he reminds us that the sum total of the Gettyburg’s Address is only 243 words.

The author further manages to weave together a fascinating amount of information on a seemingly mundane topic across chapters titled, among others: Metaphor and Money, Metaphor and the Mind, and Metaphor and Politics.

He seems to include everything on the subject, perhaps for the sake of completeness. This is not necessarily a good thing. Does a reader really need to know the neurological basis for particular conceptual metaphors? Arguably not, as it becomes less entertaining as it becomes more pedantic in the middle of the book.

Still, it’s a minor quibble. I Is an Other really shines when it focuses on the simple yet profound. “Juliet is the sun” is a sentence revisited by Geary throughout the book, and it’s an excellent choice: Is Juliet a ball of fiery gas? Or is she, to Romeo, the center of the universe and more?

Our ability to instantly understand what Shakespeare was really trying to say is a mark of both maturity and humanity, and Geary compellingly makes this point clear.

I Is an Other
feels like it could have been a superlative 250-page book instead of a very good 304-page book. Still, it has far more good points than bad points and you’ll never look at a metaphor the same way again—metaphorically speaking.

Long Description: 

James Geary’s latest book on the nuances of the English language is called I Is an Other: The Secret Life of Metaphor and How It Shapes the Way We See the World. Its existence begs the question: Is there really enough to say about metaphors for a writer—even one as talented as Mr. Geary—to fill a 304-page book?

Yes—for the most part.

First, the metaphor. It is the act of giving one thing “a name that belongs to something else,” according to Aristotle. It is how we understand the world around us. Consider the following dialogue between a king and his philosopher subject in a story retold by the author:

[T]he King said to him: “If you have anything to say, I wish you would say it plainly and not resort to analogies.”

Hui Tze said, “Suppose there is a man here who does not know what a tan is, and you say to him ‘A tan is like a tan.’ Would he understand?”

“No,” the King said.

“Then were you to say to him ‘A tan is like a bow, but has a strip of bamboo in place of the string.’ Would he understand?”

“Yes, he would,” the King replied.

“A man who explains necessarily makes intelligible that which is not known by comparing it with what is known,” Hui Tze said.

I Is an Other opines that it is near impossible to write anything without the use of a metaphor. Consider this famous American sentence:

Four score and seven years ago, our fathers brought forth, upon this continent, a new nation, conceived in liberty, and dedicated to the proposition that “all men are created equal.”

Geary counts one metaphor for every fifteen words of Lincoln’s famous speech, which is even more surprising when he reminds us that the sum total of the Gettyburg’s Address is only 243 words.

The author further manages to weave together a fascinating amount of information on a seemingly mundane topic across chapters titled, among others: Metaphor and Money, Metaphor and the Mind, and Metaphor and Politics.

He seems to include everything on the subject, perhaps for the sake of completeness. This is not necessarily a good thing. Does a reader really need to know the neurological basis for particular conceptual metaphors? Arguably not, as it becomes less entertaining as it becomes more pedantic in the middle of the book.

Still, it’s a minor quibble. I Is an Other really shines when it focuses on the simple yet profound. “Juliet is the sun” is a sentence revisited by Geary throughout the book, and it’s an excellent choice: Is Juliet a ball of fiery gas? Or is she, to Romeo, the center of the universe and more?

Our ability to instantly understand what Shakespeare was really trying to say is a mark of both maturity and humanity, and Geary compellingly makes this point clear.

I Is an Other
feels like it could have been a superlative 250-page book instead of a very good 304-page book. Still, it has far more good points than bad points and you’ll never look at a metaphor the same way again—metaphorically speaking.